Report on Malignant Diphtheria in Northern Vermont |
|
By Dr. E Harris – Dated December 15, 1879 | |
[This report was undertaken by the National Board of Health after a very serious and fatal outbreak of diphtheria was reported in Newark, Vermont. The report contains extensive reports on the families affected, as well as the families not affected, who lived in the town at the time.]
|
|
Dear Sir: In compliance with instructions from the Board I have visited the district of Northern Vermont, in which the alarming sickness and mortality were reported, and which, from the suddenness and fatality of the outbreak, was attributed to the pollution of a stream. Proceeding to visit the locality as soon as practicable after receiving your official request, I conferred, while on my way, with Prof. Henry D. Holton, of Brattleboro and Dr. C. G. Adams, of Island Pond Village, Vermont, as those esteemed physicians had already opened correspondence with me concerning the reported events. Upon reaching the township of Newark, in Caledonia County accompanied by Dr. Adams, we conferred with the "first selectmen" or superior of the town, and began an investigation of every case that had occurred. After three days I had inspected the premises, obtained the evidence and records, as given in the following report. Returning from the afflicted district by way of Saint Johnsbury, West Burke and Lunenburgh, for the purpose of conferring, with the physicians and other scientific gentlemen who had been consulted by the people of Newark, all available information and facilities were afforded to me for reviewing the results of my inspection and the records of the outbreak. The subjoined report may be regarded as complete, with the exception of the record of the last series of events, still in progress, but which ought soon to terminate with the sanitary suppression of the causes that have hitherto propagated and spread the disease. Whatever more occurs worthy of record may be appended to this report as additional information.
Divisions of the Report
Brief Description of the locality Map, Diagrams and lists Notes on the households infected and on those which were not Appended Statements First information on the outbreak (A, B and C) Topography and geology of the district (D) Habitations and domestic conditions (e) The analysis of the brook water Various contributions of information from physicians in Vermont and New Hampshire
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
In numerous leading newspapers and by letters from competent medical gentlemen in Vermont, the statements concerning a sudden and destructive outbreak of a malignant disease in Northeastern Vermont warranted the investigation which the Board directed me to undertake. Appended statements and letters, marked A B and C, show precisely the nature of the information received from sources here mentioned. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
The township of Newark, Caledonia County, with a population of 600 upon 36 square miles, is reported one of the most salubrious, and its inhabitants are notably temperate, thrifty, and well housed. In the central district of the township, in which dwell 85 persons in 14 households, there were 39 children under 16 years of age, and of these there were 22 who attended as pupils at the opening of the summer term of the common school, May 12, 1879. The school room, having less than 200 cubic feet of aerial space for each child, was occupied during the usual hours from Monday morning, May 12, till Thursday afternoon of the 15th. It is situated in the bottom of a narrow glen that slopes steeply to the southward, and an eddying and tortuous streamlet flows close along by the rear of the school house; of this water all the pupils except one drank freely, for the noonday temperature was 80 degrees Fahr. and upwards. On Wednesday evening several little children of this group were sick, and on Thursday evening several were alarmingly ill with symptoms which to their parents seemed inexplicable. The physician, who was summoned from a distant town at midnight, found his services demanded in four families. The teacher and officers of the school closed its doors on Friday morning, May 16, and before Sunday night, May 18, several of the children were already dying, and 16 out of the 22 pupils were severely sick with the disease, which, before half the number died, caused great alarm. Within three or four days of the beginning of the sickness in the families that were thus represented by the pupils the other children and the care takers in the same families were smitten by the same malady, and at last nearly all who gave themselves freely to nursing the sick, or to the care and washing of the garments defiled by the putrid matters of the mouth and nostrils, were violently attacked by the malady, even in the instances where the dwellings of such persons were several miles apart upon different hillsides. Up to the date of my return from the district there had occurred 18 cases and 14 deaths, and other deaths have occurred since my return. These events were adapted to terrify as well as cause deep anguish in so tranquil and social a community. More than half of all the inhabitants were attacked, and 16% are dead already, while nearly 30% of the cases were fatal. This has occurred in a section of the township which comprises only one seventh part of its area and population, and where only one or two deaths in that section, or in the whole township only eight or nine, usually occur in the whole year; that is, where the annual death rate has steadily been from 14 to 17 per 1,000 of the living,, it now, for the period of five weeks, from diphtheria alone, became 140 per 1,000, yearly rate, and in the district itself, had the same rate of destruction contained for a year, none would have remained alive. The accusation of the water of the streamlet that supplied the school children in that district, and the discovery of obvious causes of pollution of that brook, very readily exaggerated the relation of that suspected source of peril, which the afflicted families denounced in positive terms. This source of suspected defilement of the brook water was carerefully examined, and although the actual causes of the spread of the disease as a virulent contagion are ascertained, as described in this report, the neglect of sanitary care and provisions for that little school room and its pupils will ever be a most important part of the record of this fatal outbreak and propagation of diphtheria. The explosion phenomena of the outbreak and spread of the contagious factor of the malady certainly depended upon causes which were present in and near the little school room in the glen. The children of nine of the ten families that were represented in that school became sick from the same infectious malady, and the 16 pupils who went home infected and rapidly succumbing to the disease unquestionably planted the virus in their widely separate dwellings in the valley and on the hill sides. The alarm and grief which in this insulated region called the attention of the National Board of Health have given occasion for carefully investigating and reporting the preventable causes by which diphtheria produces its ravages and seem to become epidemic. The hillsides of a mountain district and the domestic and social circumstances of their inhabitants have enabled us to place on record the facts which more completely demonstrate the sanitary problems of control and extinction of the infections and transportable factor or cause of diphtheria, than could in cities and populous villages be clearly divested of doubt in the line of evidence. This report comprises, in concise statements, the records of the groups of cases, viz, those cases that constitute the primary group, and those which followed in successive series, a review of the physical circumstances of the households, the locality, and the season, together with an abstract of medical evidence, and the maps necessary for the illustration of the subjects referred to. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
The Locality |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Newark is the most northern township of Caledonia County, Vermont, and is 6 miles square, situated about 60 miles in a northeasterly direction from Montpelier, in latitude 44 25 north and longitude 70 55 west. Its deepest valleys have an altitude of nearly 1,250 feet above the level of the sea, while the crests and plateaus of its hills vary from 100 to 300 feet above the beds of the valleys. The eastern side of the town is flanked by a sharp spur of the Green Mountains range, shutting off a view of Mount Washington, and having an altitude 1,700 feet above the sea. Ridges and smoothed slopes of diluvial gravel and disintegrated calciferous mica schists and the eroded valley and glens that are worn in the latter, as left in the glacial period, now are prolific grass lands and forests. The valleys have a general direction from north to south, bearing eastward, and their streamlets converge to make up the west branch of the Passumpsic River, which flows onward to the Connecticut. The accompanying map shows the geographical and historical points which are to be mentioned in this report. It presents the outlines of school districts and indicates the location of the dwellings, public roads, hills, valleys, and water courses in the township. The outbreak of diphtheria was in district No. 4, and extended to district 2 and 9, and has also been transplanted in a remote quarter of No. 7. The pond and its sluggish outlet in district No. 4 occupy the most swampy depression in the main western valley of the town. That water way, notably the half mile south from the Center Pond, with a hundred acres of boggy land on either bank, comprises the most stagnant water in the town. The map will serve as a road and chart, but the profile view from a standpoint on the most Southern hillside in district 4 shows the several hills and streamlets converging in the valley southward from the school house and Center Pond. The small circles inclosing numerals mark the site of the dwellings invaded by diphtheria, those which are beyond the limits of the fourth district (Nos. 11, 14 and 15), being the exceptional dwellings, marked like the other afflicted households, by a red circle and number.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Consecutive Record of Cases |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
April 13, 1879 – The family of Mr. A. F. Carpenter, whose dwelling is marked 1 on the map, called a physician from the neighboring town of West Burke, a post village, 7 miles distant, to attend two of his children. There were two children younger than those in the family not then sick. A teamster and his invalid wife resided in the family as boarders. The two sick children, and soon the teamsters wife, were sick and under treatment until the 23rd of April. The physician pronounced the disease to be diphtheria. The invalid wife had a difficult convalescence, with her nostrils and mouth loaded repeatedly with the diplitheritic membrane. The husband recovered more rapidly, but with ":sore eyes: from which he had not recovered a the time I saw him, six weeks later. One of the children, Emma, aged about 11 years, recovered to such a degree as to be able to run about for a fortnight before the school was opened; but during the few days previously to the opening, and most notably on the day of opening (May 12), both eyes, particularly the eyelids, were loaded with "an offensive discharge". Pain in the eyes, added to this offensive condition of the eyelids, led the child to stay away from school after her first day’s attendance. I saw this child and took her own testimony; and, aside from any events which we know ensued upon her attendance at school, I should have inferred that her oplithalmia was diphtheritic. Probably the teamster, who lived in the same apartments and ate at the same table and had been sick with diphtheria at the same time, suffered this form of disease, as before mentioned, for his eyes were not fully recovered when I saw him in June.
The four cases of diphtheria in the carpenter dwelling, upon the bog, certainly had a slow and dubious convalescence; two of them were vexed with aphthalmia that continued until June; their sore throats and nostrils gave ample evidence of the nature of their sickness even at the time I saw them; therefore these four will be entered in this report as the preliminary cases. I was unable to trace these to any antecedent cases that would in any manner account for transmission of diphtheritic contagion to them. But whether this malady may spring up indigenously and take on the contagious quality, or, on the other hand, may depend on the specific germinal matter of the disease itself, conveyed by whatever means possible in air and substance, the occurrence of these from primary cases was obviously natural so far as personal, domestic and local circumstances were concerned. The type and history of the ophthalmic troubles must not be overlooked, and we have to add to this the testimony of the patient, Emma, that at the opening of the school she wore the same unwashed chemise that she wore when sick with diphtheria. This is important, if true, and all persons who undertook to test this child’s memory and veracity believe her statements. Having studied these four preliminary cases that occurred in the same apartment, we have now to consider the several series of cases that followed the primary group (whose medical history was supposed to have ended with the third week in April), In recording these successive series we found that the evidence classes them in four distinct and clearly dependent groups. Therefore, in reporting them consecutively, it will be logically correct, as well as convenient, to allow them to appear in four successive series, as we found them on our personal inspection from house to house. First Series of Cases in MayThe school children – The common school in district No 4 opened its summer term the 12th of May, with 22 pupils, and as only one family escaped the seizure of some or all of the children they sent to this school, we will mention these families in their order. Family of J. Aldrich In school there were: James, eight years of age; Jennie, five years of age; Frederick twelve years of age. James was attacked with all the throat symptoms of diphtheria on Wednesday evening, May 14 and on Thursday night he was very sick. The case proved excessively malignant the diptheritic exudation and masses invading all the mucous passages from the lips to the stomach. He died on the _____day. Previous to and closely following this first fatal case the two other little children (not pupils at school) and the father, mother and an uncle, which constituted the household of eight persons, took the same disease; Jennie, aged five years, was attacked on Friday, the 16th of May and died on the ____, Frederick, past twelve years old, was attacked about the same time as his sister, and was dangerously sick on Sunday, and died on the 26th of May, after unusual endurance of a virulent form of the malady a full week. He was carefully nursed during the last two days by a gentleman to whom he was affectionately attached, and who came from a distant part of the township to give his attendance. This boy died on the 26th, and at that date the five other members of the family had come down with the same malady, and made the second series of cases more numerous and formidable that the first series. The residence of this family is marked No 2 on the map. Family of K. Morse Delia, six years and ten months of age, became very sick in school on Thursday, the 15th of May. Symptoms: dipheritic throat, headache, stiffness, and vomiting. The physician who was called to her at midnight from a distant town had three other families to demand his attention before the next sunrise, May 16. Delia died on the 6th day from the attack. Irving, aged five years, was sick n the 16th and died on the 7th day from the attack. Uncontrolled epistaxis seemed to be the cause of his death, after the throat had become clean. The septicaemia was so marked in both these cases as to give currency to the belief and statement that the flesh was falling from their bodies while being wrapped hastily in blankets for burial immediately after death. The fact that necraemia and excessive sloughing The Family of John Cole Alvah and Frank, four and a half and six and a half years of age respectively, were attacked on Friday, the 16th of May and died on the fifth or sixth day of their sickness. Their residence is marked No. 4 The Family of A. F. Carpenter Charles, aged thirteen, who had escaped attack during four weeks of exposure to causes at his father’s house, where his brother and sister and Mr. and Mrs. Woodrough were sick, was seized with diphtheria the fourth day of school (at noon). He recovered. This case is in evidence that the conditions that favored his becoming infected at school were greater than at home. His home is marked No. 1 on the map. Family of F. Simpson Carrie and Eliza, aged eleven and twelve years, respectively, came down with diphtheria on Friday, May 16. Their residence was nearest the school room, in the glen. They recovered, but were suffering serious sequelae of the malady when I examined them, June 12. Their residence is marked No. 5. Family of Samuel Park Emma and Etta, aged eight and six years respectively, were attacked violently on the last school day, May 15. The younger girl died on the _____of May. Their residence, upon the crest of the steep hill northwest of the glen, is marked No. 6 on the map. Family of J. Gero Warren, aged twelve years, the only pupil at school from this large family of ten persons, came down with diphtheria on May 16, and, after a comparatively mild attack, recovered. This is in a family of French Canadians who live much in the open air, and who, fortunately, were only little exposed to this the mildest case of series first. This house is marked No. 7 Family of L. Wilson Clifton Hudson (a boarded child), aged eight years, and Nettie, aged five, came down with the sickness on the 14th day of May. The girl died the eleventh day of her disease. The boy recovered sufficiently to be removed to his father’s residence, twelve miles eastward. The Wilson house is marked No. 8 on the map. Family of D. Fairbanks Mystie, aged ten years, was attacked severely during the afternoon of May 14, the third day of school. As her home was upon a distant and steep hill and her younger sister an object of care, the teacher kindly led these children down home. The teacher and this youngest child had resolutely refused to drink the brook water, and as each of them mentioned this fact thus early, it is part of this record. D. Fairbanks house is marked No. 9 on the map. Review of Events in First SeriesOf the 22 school children 16 were attacked so nearly at the same time, and were so significantly sick with the same malady, and the mortality was so startling, that panic was inevitable, where in a whole township there was neither a physician nor a clergyman to explain the causes nor assuage the fears of the families in which these events occurred. The death of 9 out of these 16 certified the malignancy of the disease. The question, whence came the infectious virus of the malady, was urgently asked, and erroneously answered by the parents and their neighbors. That query now admits of a correct reply, yet the circumstances under which the pupils in the school room by the brook in the glen were gathered into close contiguity during the four hot days, drinking copiously of the polluted water, and crowded into a close little room that stood upon and beside a muck bed, may fully account for the explosive phenomena of the contagious outbreak and spread the disease. Besides these local and domestic circumstances there were others, chiefly associated with the intercourse of the family with the people of the towns where diphtheria was present. It is certain that the preliminary cases were slow and imperfect in their recovery. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
The Second Series of Cases |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Before the cases in the first series were terminated – in death or recovery – and, indeed, at the time when the first two of the nine fatal cases of that series were dying, the second series of cases began to be prostrated. The parents, nurses, and infants in the families of the first series patients or school children cases being now the victims. This second series, exceeding thirty in number, was widely distributed, and wherever it extended beyond the households of the series of school children it took hold of inhabitants of the most elevated and salubrious dwellings, that had no other cause for the presence of diphtheria than such as was accounted for in their voluntary and very unguarded exposure to it in their personal attention to the sick and their defiled clothing. The account of all cases in the second, third and fourth series, extending to the date of my departure from the district, will here be given as briefly as possible, and with no other details than such as are necessary for identification of the groups and their causes. In the Aldrich family The five members of this family not included in the first series of cases consisted of the two parents, a brother of the father, an infant of seven months, and a son, William E. aged three years. William was attacked with the disease May 19, nearly five days after his brother James came from school sick with it. Death ensued on the fifth day of the malady. The infant, Mary, who had been removed to A. F. Carpenter’s for care as soon as its mother became ill, immediately came down and died with the disease. The mother, who became ill while attending upon her three dying children in first series, was taken to a new little cottage adjacent to her own garden, and there was nursed by its occupant and recovered. Mr. Aldrich and his brother, forty years of age, were at the same time sick in the family residence, where four apartments were being occupied by patients. The acre of ground where that house is situated is an alluvial terrace neat the foot of a northern hill, the house and terrace looking southward, the cellar being were from springs, the surrounding grounds sodden with organic matter and covered with the waste of rotting wood, and the well water and grounds generally being foul with all sorts of excremental soakage. Here was the most populous and virulent focus whence radiated the disease by many carriers. The Moore Family A child two years of age was attacked by the disease the day its sister Delia died May 22. It recovered. The case of another child three and a half years of age who escaped by removal to a distant dwelling belongs to the record of escapes. Father and mother seem to have escaped, and the healthy babe born June 4 was still doing well. John Cole’s Family The father, mother, and father’s brother, all the family, were seized with the disease the day the two school children were buried. recovered. The Simpson Family The mother and an infant of two and a half years took the disease while the two school girls of the family were recovering. The infant died on the 6th day of sickness. The Park Family The eldest son, Orlo, aged thirteen, came down severely on the 10th of June, while his surviving sister was recovering. His brother Warren was seized on the 12th instant. I examined him and observed the local malady in the fances six hours before any other than the throat symptoms appeared. The result in these two cases was dubious up to the 14th instant, since which I have no tidings. The Wilson Family The disease of the two school children extended to the four adults in the family. These recovered. There was another adult(Mr. Hudson, of East Haven), the father of one of the children, who became slightly ill with the throat symptoms, but he removed with his child to his home eastward of the mountains as soon as they could go safely to themselves. In Families that had no school children The cases in the second series appeared as follows: Mr. and Mrs. McLucas, in the residence No 10, attended upon the dying in first series and suffered mild attacks. Family of Eph. Fairbanks George F., aged 31, attending the sick and school children at Mr. Aldrich’s, was severely attacked May 26 at his house, 2 1/2 miles away upon the mountain side . His step-mother, Mrs. E. Fairbanks, attended upon him continuously, and his step[-brother, Robert, shared in the duty. What occurred to the family subsequently we shall mention. This homestead is marked No 11 on the map. Miss L. Bill, a maiden of twenty eight years, attended upon Aldriches, and became sick at her house, a mile distant. Whether from exposure to cases of children in first or second series is unimportant, as she became sick soon after her attendance upon both at the same time. The children in her home had been exposed in the school, but did not suffer. They had the diphtheria last year in a distant town. That homestead is marked 12 on the map. Mrs. Gray, aged fifteen and a half years, residing with her mother in a large family (Mr. James Cole’s) of field and forest workmen, came down with diphtheria while the Wilson family was recovering. She had been exposed to the personal contagion of the malady only by the visits of the non-resident (Mr. Hudson) who removed his child from the Wilson’s, and, more notably, by her mother’s laundry work in the little apartment where she was some five or six days before her illness compelled her to call a physician. I saw this case making a slow recovery. The house is marked 13. Mr. and Mrs. Woodruff – O. C. Woodruff, aged 23, farmer, residing upon a salubrious high plateau nearly 3 miles southeast from Mr. Aldrich’s, after two nights and a day’s watching and ultimate attendance of the dying lad, Fred. Aldrich, lay down near the sufferer for some time on the 26th of May. He was seized that day, and has made a slow recovery. Even after his throat and mouth were entirely clear of the diphtheritic membrane, the same virus attacked a slight abrasion upon the back of his hand, and this was still unhealed at the time I saw it, June 12. Mrs. Woodruff, the heroic but unadvised wife, sent for the most necessary portions of the defiled personal clothing &c., at the Aldrich house on the 25th of May. She washed and ironed it at her distant and most healthful dwelling, and sent the cleaned garments and bedding to the afflicted house whence it was taken. She became severely ill on the 28th, and was dangerously so before the end of May. Those two cases, and unquestionably the latter one, clearly fix certain important points in history if the incubation as well as portability of the diphtheritic virus. The home of these thrifty people is marked No 14. The Third Series of CasesWhatever may possibly be true in such cases as those of Mrs. Gray, Miss Bill, and George Fairbanks, who were briefly in attendance on cases (or in their presence) in the second series, and had full and positive exposure to the infection from the sick in the first. Mrs. Ephraim Fairbanks, at residence No 11, attended constantly upon her step-son, George, at their mountain home, where everything was cleanly, fresh, dry, and well kept. On the ninth day of that exposure, worn down with care and toil, she came down severely. She continued to nurse her child at night until her milk failed. She died the morning of June 8, attended by her son (Mr. Roberts) and a vigorous lady friend, Mrs. Kelly, whose residence was 4 1/2 miles distant. The infant, of 22 months, had ceased nursing and been taken from the sick room three days before the mother died. It became sick the day of that death and followed the mother five days later. I visited this child when dying. Possibly these cases may be the last of the third series, though fatal cases of "some sudden sickness" have occurred during the second week of this month beyond the mountain eastward, whither the school child Clifton Hudson was removed by his father from the Wilson family in Newark, before complete recovery.
|
Date | Noonday Temperature (Fahrenheit) | Humidity (100 being saturation) |
May 12 | 78 | 32 |
May 13 | 85 | 40 |
May 14 | 81 | 35 |
May 15 | 74 | 80, showers |
May 16 | 70 | 70 |
May 17 | 72 | 65 |
May 18 | 74 | 50 |
May 19 | 75 | 68, showers |
May 20 | 65 | 45 |
This record suffices to show that the weather was intensely hot and dry during the four days the school in the glen was in session, from May 12 to 15, and that the heated term continued. Vegetation advanced rapidly, and, in the narrow little valley in which the children were at school, the heat was much greater than was marked by the observer who has kindly furnished the annexed record of temperature.
Atmospheric And Parasitical Fungi
Professor cutting, the State geologist, and eminent as a naturalist and teacher, resides in a neighboring town, and by his courtesy we are informed that "the entire region is remarkably free from any of the minute cryptogamia which are manifested as blights and molds, or that otherwise produce visible effects; that the blights and mildews which are sources of
danger in the Lower Valley of the Connecticut River are rarely found in this highland region, and that even the Puccinia graminis, as usually found in abundance in the lowland districts are where the cereals are grown, have seldom produced any obvious effects in this region of Vermont.
The Chemistry and Microscopy of the Brook Water
The streamlet which was so much accused of being the cause of the fatal outbreak among the school children has its source in numerous springs up the glen in the woodlands. Samples of the water from the woodland portion of the stream just above the point where the soakage from the meadow and barnyard have remained for four weeks free from odor and from any growth of algae and other visible organisms; while the samples which were taken at the same time from the places at which the school children obtained water are found to have become intolerably offensive, and to have become densely turbid with spore growth and animalculae. Five or six samples of the water from the last mentioned places in the brook were submitted to
Prof. Hiram A. Cutting, for analysis, by the selectmen of Newark, who hoped, by the help of the professor’s explanations and account of his analysis, to quell the panic, and either to disprove or justify the current accusations in the district. By Professor Cutting’s kindness I am permitted to present the annexed statement of the results of his analyses:
Appended Statement of the Chemistry and Microscopy of the Waters of the Brook in Newark
State of Vermont
Office of State Geologist
Lunenburg, June 14, 1879
My Dear Sir:
On May 29 I carefully examined the water brought me from a small stream in Newark. I found 24 4/5 grains of impurity to the gallon, consisting of animal, vegetable and mineral matter. The water was slightly ammoniacal, containing a trace of chloride of sodium, but no salts of lead or copper, and but slight traces of iron. Animalcule like as it appeared under the microscope was abundant, including Ratifers, Daphnia pelex, Hydrachna, and other common varieties. It was, as the tests show, but slightly contaminated by sewerage, and the impurities from animal, vegetable and
mineral matter was no greater than is usual in the small streams of Vermont in the spring time. While I consider it unfit for drinking purposes, I find nothing that would seem to be immediately detrimental to health.
In the water as it came to me were the usual algae found in what is supposed to be our purest waters. The most abundant was "Batrachospermum moniliforme". I also found in connection species of the Volvox; but nothing in the vegetating life that was abundant and in vigorous growth that would indicate any uncommon condition of the water.
Truly Yours,
Hiram A. Cutting
After conferring with all the educated physicians who had made observations on the town or among the sick during the season, I ascertained that nothing unusual or worthy of note seems to have marked the occurrences in nature, or among the people, the past two months. The diseases have been of a mild type; enteric fever has not been prevalent, though it is the malady most feared among the people. Diphtheria seemed to have nearly disappeared until April and May, and only a few small groups of cases of it have yet been reported in this region of Vermont, but none so destructive as this in Newark.
The season has been peculiar in the suddenness of the advent of hot summer weather the second and third weeks in May, before the ice had disappeared from the neighboring mountains.
The very nicely exact observations of Professor Cutting upon the presence and variations of ozone in the northern regions of Vermont have warranted him in stating that for many days in May it was entirely absent on several days; yet this, he says, is not unusual at the beginning of summer in these mountain towns. It is a fact to be noted that the several days of excessive heat, beginning May 11, were exceedingly dry, the hygrometer marking as low as .35 of saturation, while shortly before the earth was flooded by rain. The outbreak of diphtheria occurred just at the time when the minute fungi could be most favored.
Other Outbreaks of Diphtheria This Season
In the town of Barre, 70 miles southwestward from Newark, and Tunbridge, some 80 miles south, sharp and fatal outbreaks have occurred, and caused the closure of the district schools. These manifestations have not ceased. It was noticed last year that several insulated cases and small groups of sufferers from diphtheria occurred in the five northern counties of Vermont and in the two northern counties of New Hampshire. The chief of these records are appended under the head of "Recent Outbreaks in Northern Vermont and New Hampshire". Special importance attaches to the record of that in Northumberland, N.H. where 110 cases occurred in one school district which I visited. (See statements E, F, G.)
Though diphtheria has prevailed in the State to some extent from 1858 until now, its specific self propagating virus was not generally recognized until recent years among the country physicians. In 1863, when it destroyed nearly 1400 lives in the State, this contagious attribute began to be anxiously noticed; and in 1866 Dr. A.J. Hyde, of Sutton, reported for the committee on epidemics in Caledonia County, to the State Medical society of Vermont, that diphtheria had attacked some patients upon abrasions on the hand, the ankle, the os uteri, and in one instance, with fatal blood poisoning and death ensuing, it had attacked the eyes. That report awakened the medical profession to the duty of more closely observing the first cases and first groups of cases, and carefully recording the progressive events of the local outbreaks and epidemics of diphtheria.
To facilitate the inquiries now in progress respecting this malady, and also add valuable facts in connection with this report, we here refer to recent investigations by most trustworthy medical observers in the regions of Northern Vermont and New Hampshire, where the present outbreak occurred, and may be permitted to add some further testimony from the physicians in those regions, who have voluntarily opened correspondence with the National Board of Health upon this subject.
Dr. S. H. Colderwood’s report – A valuable study of 55 cases of diphtheria occurring in a region some miles northward from Newark was contributed to the Vermont State Medical Society two years ago by the late Dr. Colderwood. The events of the Newark outbreak, like those of numerous epidemics of diphtheria, have prepared the people in the regions afflicted, and probably the entire State, to accept and act upon the necessary sanitary instructions for repressing and preventing the propagation of the contagious and all known accessory factors of this malady. The numerous physicians and other enlightened citizens whom I met in the North have expressed an earnest wish that a State board of health shall be organized in every state.
Note upon an outbreak of diphtheria in the town of Northumberland, N.H. – Hon. Dr. J. A. Watson, a member of the legislature of New Hampshire, communicates the following facts concerning the remarkable prevalence of this disease in the district where he resides: In the little hamlet of Groveton, where the Grand Trunk railroad touches the Connecticut River,
diphtheria appeared in a public school, at which 125 pupils were in attendance, in May 1878. The local conditions under which the disease rapidly spread to 25 of the pupils, regardless of the domestic relations and distance of their families, induced me to inspect the locality and the
great school house in the mountains, for the special facts which Hon. Dr. Watson has since contributed seemed to be very important, as communicated to me by a citizen of that district.
Groveton, NH
June 30, 1879
Dear Doctor: Your letter received, and should have answered before, but have been sick, and am not yet well. I inclose you a rough diagram of the field of the epidemic of which you write and also some points relating to its origin.
Respectfully,
J.A. Watson, M.D.
On the 12th day of May last a case of diphtheria made its appearance in a family of means and respectability in the village of Groveton. Everything around the premises was neat, clean and orderly, and the hygienic and sanitary surroundings were above the average. The patient was a boy of about eight years of age. There was no other case of diphtheria in town, and no connection between this and any other case could either directly or indirectly be traced. The boy was attending school at the time of the invasion of the disease and was in excellent health.
On May 19, seven days after the onset of the first case, a little girl about 10 years of age was taken with the same disease. This patient lived nearly a mile from the first case, a little out of the village, on a farm. Here the sanitary conditions were also good, though the case was of a most malignant character, and the patient dies on the sixth day after the invasion of the disease. This little girl was also attending school.
May 21. Another case, remote from the other two, and in no way exposed to the former cases: was attending school.
May 22. Two new cases in different localities, remote from all former cases; both scholars.
May 23. One new case – a scholar
May 24. Five new cases – scholars.
May 25. Five new cases – scholars
May 26. Six new cases – scholars.
May 27. Six new cases – scholars
May 28. Two new cases – scholars.
By this time the whole village was thoroughly infected and the disease was no longer exclusively confined to school children, but attacked others in the family that already had a case, and in many instances seeming to spring up independently of any connection with any case, and without regard to individual sanitary conditions.
Origin – It will be remembered that the first twenty five cases were from among children attending school, and that their homes were in many instances quite widely separated; that as many as twenty two cases occurred in the short space of six hours. What, then, must be the
conclusion arrived at, even by those whose philosophy does not extend outside the lappet of their purse?
No one can doubt for a moment that these cases originated from a common source, and nowhere else could a common origin be found but at the school house or its immediate vicinity; so a most careful examination was instituted, with the following results.
There was at that time no diphtheria in any of the surrounding towns; there was no case of the kind within the limits of Northumberland; not one of the school children or any resident of the village had been away and returned; so it was not imported: and yet twenty five scholars were almost simultaneously stricken with this fearful disease. A common origin must be
undoubted. Eliminating then, considerations which might under other circumstances have been factors, I would ask you what remains as a cause? The answer is given in one small word – a word to which should be attached the death emblem of the skull and cross bones ad a warning to every community, every family, and every individual – the word filth.
Map showing the locality of the epidemic in Groveton (Northumberland) NH
Dear Sir: I have been waiting for the terminating of the last cases of diphtheria. Mrs. Kelly has had a bad time from the toxic effects of the diphtheria. I thought, or rather, was fearful, she would die from the paralysis, but she is getting along finely. We kept the people and the children from going into the sick room, and no one has contracted the disease from her. One of the Simpson children went to their uncles, near East Haven, three weeks ago last Saturday and stayed a few hours, and in four days two of the children were taken with diphtheria. One lived five or six days and other eleven days. The mother and two more children were taken with diphtheria and sent for me. They are all getting better. There are three cases now in East Haven. Dr. Ide is attending them; three have died and he thought one more would die. The people have done something towards disinfecting the Muse Hollow, but have not done what they should. I have said and done all I can to have things thorough with the disinfectants, but know how people after the excitement is over are apt to cease from trying to cleanse their houses. I shall continue to do all in my power to correct unsanitary families in the Hollow. I would like to see you and learn all I could. I hope the diphtheria is arrested. If they are careful in East Haven I think it may stop. There is no other way to do. Mrs. Wilson, of Newark, called on me today with a bad throat, effect of former disease.
Park’s children were very sick after you left, but they are all well now. I do not think of more cases that have occurred. I should like to call and see you; I thank you for the instructions you gave me; I shall always remember you, and my earnest prayer is for your success in arresting the diphtheria and all kindred diseases of like nature. I hope toy may live long and be permitted to relieve the suffering [-art of community. If you come to Vermont, call and see me.
I am truly your friend,
WW Carpenter.
East Burke, Vt.
July 19, 1879
Dear Doctor: Yours came duly to hand. I have delayed answering sooner from the fact there has been a succession of cases in the neighborhood to which you refer. The man whom you mention, Mr. Henderson, brought his child from Newark to his former home, a distance of about eight miles, before it had recovered from diphtheria. This child was visited by a playmate, a little girl, on Friday; on the following Monday I was sent for and found the child to be suffering from a severe attack of diphtheria. The disease ran a rapid course, the child dying within a week. This was an adopted child, one of a family of six belonging to a Mr. Hosford, and lived in the family of a Mr. Henderson (not the one whose child was sick in Newark). During its illness no one saw it except its parents, who lived at a distance of forty rods from the dwelling of Mr. Henderson, The remaining children have all been attacked, two have recovered, two have died and one is yet sick.
I have seen the teacher of District No 4, in Newark, who informs me that she noticed nothing until the third day of school, when two of the scholars vomited and complained of headache, and manifested a disinclination to play or study. The next day they were unable to come to school, and by night there were several cases. Those that I have seen have been cases of pure, simple, if I may so use the word, cases of diphtheria uncomplicated by ophthamalia or anything else. There have been some other cases of imported diphtheria very near the village of East Haven, that have been treated by Dr. Carpenter, who will be very glad to give you the particulars. If I can oblige you any further in this matter please command me.
Yours, Very truly,
HC Ide, MD
PS. If there are any details that I have failed to give you that would be of service to you please remind me of them, and I will very gladly give them to you. I might perhaps mention that the sanitary condition of the Hossford’s resembled very much some of those you saw in Newark.
H.C.I.
Island Pond
July 9, 1879
Dear Sir: I have learned that diphtheria was carried from Lyndon to Lunenburgh, and that some cases occurred near a lumber mill in Lunenburgh, and that some of the men from the Lunenburgh mill went to the Carpenter’s in Newark. If this is true it furnishes the missing link in our research. If I get positive evidence I will inform you. I have no doubt the disease was introduced in this manner, and the time is coming when seclusion and disinfection will be practiced as closely as in smallpox. Then we shall have the thing under control. Up to July 3 four cases and three deaths in the "Lost Nation" (East Haven), every one of them traceable to contact with the disease in others.
Yours, Truly,
CG Adams
No other disease in or Northern States has been more generally regarded as unpreventable and none more capricious and fatally obstinate in its mode of prevalence than diphtheria. Its apparently and very probably sporadic origin in numerous instances, its invasion of the most salubrious as well as the most insalubrious quarters, its variable malignancy, and its rapid fatality in numerous cases, wherever it prevails, have furnished ample occasions for the unsettled opinions and sanitary regulations which prevail in regard to this destructive malady. Medical men no longer reject the conclusion which experience has taught concerning the personally contagious attribute of diphtheria; but as this attribute is variable in its intensity in different cases and on different occasions, apparently, sanitary precautions and regulations adopted to extinguish or wholly control the virus of this disease are only occasionally applied and enforced. Fortunately, the leading physicians of Vermont have correct
views upon this subject; but in the scattered population of the State, and with no central board of health, there has been no general diffusion of precise information and sanitary advice in regard to regulations and duties required in the presence of diphtheria in a community.
All the physicians and other educated men I met in Vermont and New Hampshire expressed an earnest desire that a State Board of Health should be created in each state for the special purpose of accumulating correct and needed information and diffusing the king of knowledge and advice, as well as aiding to establish regulations which the people need for protection against disease.
The fact that immediately upon learning of the outbreak of diphtheria in Newark, and of the interest taken by the National Board of Health, no less than twelve experienced physicians communicated to me important information of other outbreaks and the sanitary lessons they presented, is good proof of the cordial interest of medical men in the beneficent ends sought in this particular investigation. Each physician and every public man who I have consulted, or form whom information has been received, advises that even for the smaller states, like Vermont, there should be an efficient State Board of Health.
The tragic results of the outbreak of the disease in the little mountain district, as we have studied the facts, show that whatever were the sources of the first case – which was so mild as to awaken no concern – the conditions under which the contagious attribute of the malady became fatally intensified ought to have been prevented by a kind of sanitary supervision which should be exercised over all school buildings and their outfitting. The neglect to supply pure water and insure the exclusion of all foul water for use of the pupils, the neglect to protect the school room against impurity of the ground, air or sodden ground of the locality,
and altogether, the bad location of the school house, would have been worthy the advisory care of a State sanitary officer. The local school officer in any district in Caledonia County, and particularly in the afflicted school district we have described, would respond to such counsel
from such a responsible source. Even before I left Newark the school officers of the smitten district called a meeting of the inhabitants to determine upon a more suitable site for a new school house, and as the wealthy citizen who had been accused of wanton defilement of the brook was the largest tax payer, I obtained from him an earnest expression of his purpose to give success to the project for a new and better location and building.
The readiness of the hard working farmers, who as "selectmen" are the town council, to act immediately upon their responsibility as a local board of health, and to provide for necessary advice to the families and for skilled nurses, and specific sanitary regulations for the sick from the hour the suggestion was given, teaches a lesson never to be forgotten where local authorities need to be advised in regard to public health duties. Medical practitioners everywhere urge the necessity of a central and authorized source for specific public advise and directions to the people when peril from preventable causes of disease is imminent. The more scattered the population and the less intimate and near the relations of the families to their medical attendants, the more necessary the central source of advice and direction to the people. Physicians say they wish to repeat and promulgate such advice, and prefer, also, that it be communicated with adequate official significance.
This is not the proper occasion for presenting an array of evidence upon the subject of control and extinction of the preventable causes of diphtheria, yet I must say that the reward for a tedious inspection from house to house in a mountain region has been unexpectedly ample in the one result which was most desired, namely, the prompt and successful suppression of panic and error, and an equally successful suppression of the farther propagation of the disease by the adoption of simple and adequate sanitary measures.
Diagram showing location of school room
This design is incredible! You certainly know how to keep a reader entertained.
Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to
start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Great job.
I really enjoyed what you had to say, and
more than that, how you presented it. Too cool!
Comment by Slopeunblocked.com — June 12, 2018 @ 4:19 pm